Private AI Implementation Realities
SMB & individual readiness checklist before you over-engineer
This checklist targets individual power users and small teams. Large enterprise requirements (SSO, audit, multi-tenant governance) are intentionally excluded—see the Enterprise Scaling Guide if you truly need them.
⚠️ Before You Start: Reality Check (Avoid Premature Complexity)
Most SMBs don't need a "stack"—they need a repeatable workflow: a local model (or two), a retrieval layer, and disciplined document curation. Treat everything else (agents, fine-tuning, distributed infra) as optional experiments, not table stakes.
💻 Hardware & Resource Requirements
💰 True Cost Analysis
Upfront Hardware Investment:
- RTX 4090 (24GB): $1,600-2,000
- Mac Studio M2 Ultra: $4,000-6,000
- High-end Linux workstation: $3,000-8,000
Ongoing Costs:
- Electricity: $20-100/month (depending on usage)
- Maintenance and upgrades: $200-500/year
- Time investment: 2-10 hours/month for management
Compare to: GPT-4 subscription at $20/month or API usage at $0.01-0.06 per 1K tokens
🔧 Technical Maintenance Burden
Model Quality Reality Check
Use Case | Cloud Models (GPT-4/Claude) | Local Models (Llama-3/Mistral) | Recommendation | Local viable for most use cases |
---|---|---|---|
Code Generation | Excellent | Good | Local good for standard tasks |
Complex Reasoning | Excellent | Limited | Cloud preferred for complex analysis |
Document Summarization | Excellent | Excellent | Local ideal for this use case |
Research & Analysis | Excellent | Good | Depends on depth required |
Language Translation | Excellent | Limited | Cloud strongly preferred |
Domain-Specific Tasks | Good | Excellent* | *With proper fine-tuning |
🎯 User Experience Considerations
📊 Data Currency & Updates
🚨 When Private AI May Not Be Right for You
- Limited Technical Skills: If troubleshooting software feels overwhelming
- Tight Deadlines: When you need maximum model capability for critical tasks
- Team Collaboration: If you need shared context and multi-user access
- Hardware Constraints: Working on older or resource-limited machines
- High Availability Needs: When downtime isn't acceptable
- Cutting-Edge Requirements: Need for the latest model capabilities
✅ Getting Started Checklist
If you've checked most boxes above, here's your implementation roadmap:
- Start Small: Begin with Ollama and a 7B parameter model
- Test Use Cases: Validate model quality for your specific needs
- Measure Performance: Compare response times and accuracy
- Build Gradually: Add RAG, better hardware, and orchestration over time
- Plan Fallbacks: Keep cloud AI access for complex tasks
The Bottom Line
Private AI is powerful but not effortless. It requires:
- Meaningful upfront investment (time and money)
- Ongoing technical maintenance
- Acceptance of quality/speed trade-offs
- Clear understanding of your threat model
It's ideal when: Privacy concerns outweigh convenience costs, you have the technical capability to maintain it, and your use cases match local model strengths.
Consider cloud AI when: You need maximum capability, minimal maintenance, team collaboration, or lack the resources for local deployment.
Part of the Private AI article series by Josh Kaner