⚠️ Before You Start: Reality Check (Avoid Premature Complexity)

Most SMBs don't need a "stack"—they need a repeatable workflow: a local model (or two), a retrieval layer, and disciplined document curation. Treat everything else (agents, fine-tuning, distributed infra) as optional experiments, not table stakes.

💻 Hardware & Resource Requirements

💰 True Cost Analysis

Upfront Hardware Investment:

  • RTX 4090 (24GB): $1,600-2,000
  • Mac Studio M2 Ultra: $4,000-6,000
  • High-end Linux workstation: $3,000-8,000

Ongoing Costs:

  • Electricity: $20-100/month (depending on usage)
  • Maintenance and upgrades: $200-500/year
  • Time investment: 2-10 hours/month for management

Compare to: GPT-4 subscription at $20/month or API usage at $0.01-0.06 per 1K tokens

🔧 Technical Maintenance Burden

Model Quality Reality Check

Private AI Implementation Realities Checklist

A practical guide to the tradeoffs, requirements, and best practices for deploying private AI in your organization.

Use Case Cloud Models (GPT-4/Claude) Local Models (Llama-3/Mistral) Recommendation
Local viable for most use cases
Code Generation Excellent Good Local good for standard tasks
Complex Reasoning Excellent Limited Cloud preferred for complex analysis
Document Summarization Excellent Excellent Local ideal for this use case
Research & Analysis Excellent Good Depends on depth required
Language Translation Excellent Limited Cloud strongly preferred
Domain-Specific Tasks Good Excellent* *With proper fine-tuning

🎯 User Experience Considerations

📊 Data Currency & Updates

🚨 When Private AI May Not Be Right for You

  • Limited Technical Skills: If troubleshooting software feels overwhelming
  • Tight Deadlines: When you need maximum model capability for critical tasks
  • Team Collaboration: If you need shared context and multi-user access
  • Hardware Constraints: Working on older or resource-limited machines
  • High Availability Needs: When downtime isn't acceptable
  • Cutting-Edge Requirements: Need for the latest model capabilities

✅ Getting Started Checklist

If you've checked most boxes above, here's your implementation roadmap:

  1. Start Small: Begin with Ollama and a 7B parameter model
  2. Test Use Cases: Validate model quality for your specific needs
  3. Measure Performance: Compare response times and accuracy
  4. Build Gradually: Add RAG, better hardware, and orchestration over time
  5. Plan Fallbacks: Keep cloud AI access for complex tasks

The Bottom Line

Private AI is powerful but not effortless. It requires:

  • Meaningful upfront investment (time and money)
  • Ongoing technical maintenance
  • Acceptance of quality/speed trade-offs
  • Clear understanding of your threat model

It's ideal when: Privacy concerns outweigh convenience costs, you have the technical capability to maintain it, and your use cases match local model strengths.

Consider cloud AI when: You need maximum capability, minimal maintenance, team collaboration, or lack the resources for local deployment.

Part of the Private AI article series by Josh Kaner